|
Natural
Trails & Waters Coaliton Press Release
March
20, 2002
Anti-National Parks Bill Advances
Rep. Rush Holt's move to uphold public process and protect parks narrowly
defeated
Contact:
Sean Smith, Bluewater Network (415) 788-3666 x149
Kristen Brengel, Natural Trails and Waters Coalition (202) 429-2694
Washington DC: Today, the House Resource Committee passed HR. 3853,
a bill that contains language to delay protection for twenty one
National Parks from jet ski abuse. This legislation, introduced
by California Congressman George Radanovich and labeled a "technical
corrections" bill, interferes with a National Park Service
rulemaking that has strong public support and undermines a federal
court settlement. Congressman Rush Holt of New Jersey offered an
amendment to strike the jet ski extension language from the bill.
Holt's amendment narrowly lost a recorded vote. The bill now advances
for a floor vote.
"Once again, the Resource Committee leadership has placed
personal watercraft industry's agenda above the protection of our
beloved National Parks," said Sean Smith, Bluewater Network's
Public Lands Director and former Park ranger. "Thankfully,
Representative Rush Holt is fighting these efforts and defending
the best interests of the American public and our parks."
PWC, better known by the trade name jet ski, are known to cause
significant damage to air and water quality, visitor enjoyment,
public health and safety, natural soundscapes, and wildlife. Since
1988, several National Park units have decided to close their waters
to jet skis to protect natural resources, wildlife, and other park
visitors. At Cape Cod National Seashore, a citizen-led advisory
commission found that personal watercraft use was incompatible with
the park's enabling legislation that sought to preserve not only
unique lands and waters, but also protect values like solitude and
tranquility. At Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area, the
Park Service held three public meetings and conducted a public comment
period. Ninety-six percent of those who commented favored a ban
on personal watercraft use in the park.
"Time and time again, jet skis have been found to degrade
the environment and the public's enjoyment of National Parks,"
said Kristen Brengel, Campaign Coordinator for the Natural Trails
and Waters Coalition, a national coalition of over 90 groups working
to protect public land and waters from the abuse caused by jet skis
and other off-road vehicles. "We applaud the efforts of Representative
Holt to protect these special places now and in the future."
In March 2000, the National Park Service finalized regulations
that prohibit personal watercraft operation in roughly 67 parks,
but 21 parks were exempted from this ban. In August 2000, Bluewater
Network challenged the regulations in court (Bluewater Network v.
Stanton). The following April, a settlement was approved that requires
all parks excluded from the system-wide ban to conduct environmental
reviews and adopt special regulations, if long-term jet ski use
is to continue. Park waters would be closed to jet skis if the work
is not completed by court ordered deadlines. In eight of these units
- five national seashores, one lakeshore, and two national recreation
areas - park superintendents have already determined that jet ski
use is incompatible with the mission of their respective unit due
to public safety, wildlife, and natural resource impacts. HR 3853
would throw these decisions in doubt.
"Almost two years ago to this day, the Park Service determined
that most jet ski use in park units is inconsistent with its mission
to protect natural resources and public safety-the public agreed,"
said Sean Smith.
The National Park Service's Organic Act states that the agency's
mission is "to conserve the scenery and the natural and historic
objects and the wildlife therein and to provide for the enjoyment
of the same in such manner and by such means as will leave them
unimpaired for the enjoyment of future generations." Subsequent
park-related legislation has re-affirmed that the Park Service's
preservation mandate takes priority over its responsibility to provide
recreational opportunities.
"This anti-National Parks legislation has received no hearings
for the public and Congress to hear out both sides of the issue,"
said Kristen Brengel. "The legislation is being pushed through
without considering the damage caused by jet skis."
Return to Press Room or Press
Release Archives
|